One of the readings
I have encountered in a literature essay that I’ve pretty much
finished, is a short story by Kurt Vonnegut called Welcome To The
Monkey House. The story is set in an overpopulated dystopian future
where the use of ‘ethical’ birth control numbs all feeling below
the waist. The ethical birth control is mandatory, and anyone who
refuses to use it is called a nothinghead. On top of the ethical
birth control, another measure to handle the overpopulation situation
is the suicide clinics, akin to the suicide booths seen in Futurama
(no, Fry, that’s NOT a telephone booth).
Though the story was somewhat
odd, I was enjoying it for the most part. At least, I was until the
character it follows, Nancy—one of the suicide nurses—is
kidnapped by the bad guy in the story, Billy the Poet. Despite being
the bad guy, the story is written in such a way that it tries to make
you sympathise with her kidnapper. Sympathising with the
aforementioned kidnapper was made pretty much impossible when near
the end of the story he has his group of rebel nothingheads hold
Nancy down, then he proceeds to rape her whilst holding a gun to her
head. Though in the story rape is never mentioned, no, it’s called
deflowering. To add sting to the rape… well, how about I just quote
the scene:
"The women who helped you
tonight--"
"What about them?"
"You've done to them what
you did to me?"
He didn't look up from his book.
"That's right."
"Then why don't they kill
you instead of helping you?"
"Because they understand."
And then he added mildly, "They're grateful."
Nancy got out of bed, came to the
table, gripped the edge of the table, leaned close to him. And she
said to him tautly, "I am not grateful."
"You will be."
The rapist tells her she will be
grateful. Now, I’m not quite sure what the narrator is trying to
get across here. In the story, the ethical birth control has worn off
on Nancy at the time, and to show her what sex is like Billy the Poet
rapes her. It is intended as some sort of sexual liberation. The
dystopian future is used as an excuse to frame a story where rape
might be deemed an appropriate thing. Maybe I’m reading it wrong,
and Vonnegut isn’t all for the rape. But it really seems like he
is. People will likely tell me I’m interpreting this all wrong, but
I couldn’t help but draw parallels from this to corrective rape
happening in South Africa. Lesbians and transgender women in South
Africa have been raped in a bid to ‘cure’ them of their
respective sexual and gender orientations.1
And it’s absolutely sickening. This is exactly the same thing.
The icing on the cake was finding
out that this short story was originally published in Playboy
magazine. The suicide nurse, Nancy, is sexualised by her attire, and
is a virgin. It’s exceedingly difficult for me to interpret this in
a non sexual way. All I see is an excuse for rape to be in his story,
and somehow be justified, then published for thousands of horny men
in the sixties to read. I only had a measly 250 or so words in which
to talk about this in the essay, as there were other readings to be
analysed, but I think I managed to get my complaints across. This
blog post is simply an added unstructured rant to go on top of it.
It’s also a place where I can say how disappointed I am to have
this be my first Kurt Vonnegut story. I enjoyed his style of writing,
and I enjoyed his humour. But I know any future readings of his
stories will be coloured by my feelings from having read this. The
fact that I am so disappointed in Welcome To The Monkey house doesn’t
fill me with any enthusiasm to discover more of his work, and that’s
quite saddening.
In other, less dreary news, I’ve
finished the first draft of my literature essay! Which is a nice
accomplishment. It’s only Tuesday, and it’s not due until Friday.
All I really have left is some proofreading, and if needed a bit of
rewriting. This is a rather refreshing feeling for me considering my
general non-studious ways. On top of having the essay pretty much
done, I have also—finally—taken the time to write some more of
the novel I’m working on. Which is awesome—getting writing done
is awesome, the novel is still amateur level trash, but it’s my
amateur level trash damn it! One day I may even talk about what the
story is about here, if any interest is professed (this is making the
assumption that anyone actually reads this blog).
I’ve also just finished a
rather sarcastic short fantasy novel by Sarah Rees Brennan. Or, it’s
sort of a novel, anyway, you can find out more about it—and
actually read the whole thing—here.
I implore you to check her out. It’s the first thing of hers I’ve read since the Demon’s Lexicon back when I was oh, eighteen or so, and it’s quite a fun read. Despite the, ah, awkward young age of the relatively sexual protagonist.
I implore you to check her out. It’s the first thing of hers I’ve read since the Demon’s Lexicon back when I was oh, eighteen or so, and it’s quite a fun read. Despite the, ah, awkward young age of the relatively sexual protagonist.
#
It’s been raining for the last
few days. I’ve had the washing up since the weekend, and have still
yet to take it down. I don’t have enough room to hang it all up
inside. In fact, it’s pouring out there as I write this blog. I’m
only pretending to be an adult, really.
I’m still trying to find my
feet in the blogosphere. I reckon if I stick at it long enough I’ll
figure out what it is that I’m doing, and what it is that I want to
say.
Novel word count: 63,461
-----
No comments:
Post a Comment